Flow rate, concentration, gas composition and operating hours decide which VOC treatment unit will pay off. We compare the RTO, catalytic oxidation, the zeolite concentrator and activated carbon.
CONTENTS
IN SHORT
Several technologies remove more than 95% of VOCs from exhaust gases. The problem is that, for a specific emission, usually only one is a good fit. The others either cost too much to run or fall short when production changes. Before you start comparing units, you need four figures for the emission: flow rate, concentration, composition and operating pattern.
Flow rate. Expressed in Nm³/h. It determines the size of the unit and, above all, how much air has to be heated or passed through a bed. Treating 3,000 Nm³/h from a dryer is not the same as treating 80,000 Nm³/h from a paint shop.
Concentration. Expressed in g/Nm³ or mg C/Nm³. It has the biggest effect on the operating cost. VOCs burn and give off heat: above a certain concentration, a regenerative oxidizer holds its temperature with almost no fuel. Below that point, every cubic meter treated uses gas or electricity.
Composition. What matters is which solvents the gas contains and what comes with them. Chlorinated and fluorinated compounds form acids when oxidized, so a gas scrubbing stage has to be added. Silicones leave silica, which blocks the beds and poisons catalysts. Dust and paint aerosols require a prefilter.
Operating pattern. A plant that runs 24 hours a day all week and one with a single shift and frequent shutdowns should not have the same unit. Thermal oxidizers take time to heat up and use energy at every start-up. Activated carbon copes well with intermittent operation.
Other data are also useful: the gas humidity and temperature, whether the plant needs steam or hot water, and whether there is a natural gas connection.
This is the most common choice for medium and large flow rates and low or medium concentrations. The gas passes through a hot ceramic bed, is oxidized at 750–950 °C in a common chamber and, on the way out, gives off its heat to a second bed. The valves reverse the flow direction every cycle. More details in the RTO datasheet.
1 Combustion chamber with burner 2 Ceramic beds 3 Fan 4 Stack
If the plant wants to do without natural gas, there is the electric RTO (e-RTO). The towers and beds stay the same, but the chamber is heated by electric elements instead of a burner. No combustion NOx forms, and above the autothermal point the heating elements switch off.
The catalyst makes it possible to oxidize VOCs at 250–450 °C, much lower than in a thermal oxidizer. With low concentration and moderate flow rate, that means lower energy use.
Its weak point is compounds that destroy the catalyst: silicones, sulfur, halogens and metals. If they are present in the gas, it is better to rule out this technology or protect the bed. More information in the catalytic oxidation datasheet.
These units work with a burner and a heat exchanger instead of ceramic beds. They make sense with small flow rates, from 1,000 to 10,000 Nm³/h, and high concentrations. Also when the plant can use the surplus heat as steam, hot water or thermal oil. At low concentrations they use a lot of fuel, and an RTO usually works out cheaper. See the recuperative oxidation and direct oxidation datasheets.
It is used with large flow rates and low concentrations, below 1 g/Nm³. A zeolite rotor retains the VOCs and then releases them into an air flow up to 16 times smaller. That smaller, more concentrated flow goes to a much smaller RTO or catalytic oxidizer. It is the typical solution for paint booths and buildings with general ventilation. More information in the zeolite concentrator datasheet.
Carbon retains VOCs in its pores. It works well with low concentrations, small and medium flow rates and intermittent processes, and also with odors. When it is saturated, it is replaced or regenerated. On-site regeneration, with steam or inert gas, makes it possible to recover the solvent for reuse. At high concentrations, the carbon is used up quickly and the cost of replacing it shoots up. More details in the activated carbon adsorption datasheet.
A less well-known option, useful for specific compounds that dissolve well in a chosen liquid: light halogenated compounds, aldehydes or carbon disulfide. The liquid is regenerated by distillation or sent to biological treatment. See the solvent scrubber datasheet.
| Type of emission | Technology to look at first |
|---|---|
| Medium or large flow rate, low or medium concentration, continuous operation | RTO or e-RTO |
| Moderate flow rate, low concentration, no silicones or halogens | Catalytic oxidation |
| Small flow rate, high concentration, heat demand at the plant | Recuperative oxidation |
| Very large flow rate and concentration below 1 g/Nm³ | Zeolite concentrator + oxidizer |
| Small flow rate, intermittent emission or odor problem | Activated carbon |
| Halogenated compounds or acids in the emission | Oxidizer + gas scrubbing, or a specific scrubber |
This table is for ruling options out at the start, not for deciding. Two plants with the same flow rate can end up with different units because of the gas composition or the price of energy.
Many inquiries come with an approximate flow rate and no concentration data, or with a single measurement taken at low production. With that data, any quote is a gamble. If the unit is undersized, it will not meet the limit. If it is oversized, the plant will pay for years for energy it does not need.
A stack measurement campaign covering a full production cycle should provide, at a minimum:
With this data, the real operating costs of two or three options can be compared and the one that best fits production chosen. Descriptions of all the units are in our technology catalog.
Usually from around 1.5 g/Nm³ of VOCs. The exact point depends on the solvent composition and the heat recovery of each unit.
When the flow rate is very large and the concentration is below roughly 1 g/Nm³. The concentrator reduces the flow going to the oxidizer by up to 16 times.
Rarely. At high concentrations, the carbon saturates quickly and the cost of replacing or regenerating it exceeds that of an oxidizer.
AUTHOR
WIZZUM engineering teamWe design and commission wastewater and gas treatment installations for industry, from benchmarking and FEED engineering to start-up.
NEED HELP?
27/02/2024
Efficiency, operating temperature, energy use and maintenance of the three most widely used technologies, and how to choose the right one for your plant.
Read the article →
06/06/2023
Are eco-friendly alternatives always better? A technical view without greenwashing.
Read the article →
19/09/2023
Air and gas measurements help you control emissions, improve air quality and comply with regulations.
Read the article →
OFFICE
Avda. Cabrera, 36
08302 Mataró (Barcelona), Spain
info@wizzum.com
© 2026 Wizzum. All rights reserved.
