Biofilter, biotrickling filter, bioscrubber or chemical scrubbing. Which compounds cause odors at wastewater treatment and composting plants and how the treatment is chosen.
CONTENTS
IN SHORT
Odor complaints almost always come from outside the plant: from a neighbor, the town council, a new housing development that has crept closer to the treatment plant. A unit on the stack will not solve them on its own. Before choosing the treatment, you need to know which compounds smell, where they are produced and how to capture them.
Odor rarely comes from a single compound. At wastewater treatment plants, sulfur compounds predominate: hydrogen sulfide (H₂S), mercaptans and organic sulfides such as dimethyl sulfide. They are produced at pumping stations, grit chambers, thickeners and sludge dewatering.
At composting and waste treatment plants, ammonia is added, released during fermentation and turning of the windrows, along with amines, organic acids and various VOCs.
The composition of the mixture matters, because each technology works well with some compounds and poorly with others.
Many of these compounds can be detected at minute concentrations, far below occupational exposure limits and the threshold of portable detectors. That is why a plant can comply with occupational health and safety regulations and still cause complaints a kilometer away.
| Compound | Approximate odor threshold | Odor | Where it occurs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hydrogen sulfide (H₂S) | 0.00041 ppm | Rotten eggs | Sewers, sludge, digesters |
| Methanethiol | 0.00007 ppm | Rotten cabbage | Sludge, protein decomposition |
| Dimethyl sulfide | 0.003 ppm | Cabbage, seafood | Composting plants, wastewater treatment plants |
| Ammonia | 1.5 ppm | Pungent, irritating | Composting plants, sludge drying |
| Trimethylamine | 0.000032 ppm | Fish | Animal by-products, sludge |
| Butyric acid | 0.00019 ppm | Rancid butter | Food waste, sludge cake |
| Skatole | 0.0000056 ppm | Fecal | Sewage sludge, manure |
These are indicative laboratory values. The actual threshold depends on the method, humidity and mixture, so they are useful for setting priorities, not as a legal limit.
A simple way to find out which compound dominates is to divide the measured concentration by its odor threshold. If the result is much greater than 1, that compound contributes to the odor even if there is very little of it. This explains why ammonia at a few ppm is sometimes less of a nuisance than a few ppb of mercaptans. In mixtures, the effects do not simply add up: some compounds mask others or reinforce them. That is why chemical analysis is complemented with olfactometry.
H₂S has another peculiarity: at high concentrations it numbs the sense of smell and can no longer be detected, just when it becomes dangerous. Never use your nose to judge whether a confined space is safe.
Good treatment with poor capture does not solve the problem. Odor sources have to be covered or enclosed, and the extracted air taken to the installation. The better the enclosure, the less air has to be moved and the smaller and cheaper the installation will be. In composting buildings, for example, it is best to extract mainly from the fermentation zones rather than evenly across the whole building.
The same plant usually has several very different streams: air with a lot of ammonia from active composting, air with sulfur compounds from anaerobic zones, air with terpenes from shredding green waste and lightly loaded general ventilation. Treating it all together with a single technology is possible, but it is not always the most reliable or the cheapest option. Separating the concentrated streams from general ventilation usually gives a smaller system with lower consumption. At a wastewater treatment plant, sending the H₂S-rich air from pretreatment and dewatering to a scrubber, and the rest to a biofilter, can reduce odor by 98% and H₂S by 99%.
The humidified air passes through a bed of organic material (bark, wood chips, mature compost) or inorganic material, home to microorganisms that break down the odorous compounds. It needs no reagents. More details in the biofilter datasheet.
1 Biological bed 2 Irrigation 3 Air distribution plenum 4 Fan and humidifier
It is the most common solution at composting plants and wastewater treatment plants because of its low operating cost. Its weak points are the space it takes up and its sensitivity to concentration peaks. With a lot of ammonia or H₂S, a chemical scrubbing stage ahead of it is advisable.
It works on the same biological principle, but on an inert plastic packing continuously irrigated with recirculated water. The pH and nutrients are controlled in the loop. It takes up much less space than a biofilter and accepts higher concentrations. It is particularly suited to H₂S, because pH control neutralizes the acids formed as it breaks down. It needs more supervision and produces a liquid bleed. See the biotrickling filter datasheet.
It absorbs the pollutants in a solution with microorganisms, which then break them down in a reactor tank. It works well with highly soluble compounds, such as alcohols, and with small flows at high concentration. It is a particularly good fit for plants that already have a biological treatment plant. More information in the bioscrubber datasheet.
A packed column in which the air is scrubbed countercurrent with a solution that reacts with the pollutants:
1 Mist eliminator 2 Packing 3 Tank with recirculation pump 4 Reagent dosing
These are compact units that respond quickly to peaks and have very stable efficiency. In return, they use reagents and produce a bleed. At plants with a lot of ammonia and sulfur compounds they are combined in series: acid scrubbing first and then oxidizing. The order matters: if ammonia reaches the hypochlorite, chloramines form. See also the chemical scrubber datasheet.
| Situation | Usual solution |
|---|---|
| Municipal wastewater treatment plant, moderate H₂S, plenty of space | Biofilter |
| Little space and high H₂S | Biotrickling filter or alkaline or oxidizing scrubber |
| Composting plant with a lot of ammonia | Acid scrubbing + biofilter |
| Strong peaks or mixed compounds | Multi-stage scrubber + biofilter or dry filter |
| Small flow rate, intermittent odor | Dry filter with carbon or chemical adsorbent |
There is no single method. Each one answers a different question:
| Method | What it gives | What it is for |
|---|---|---|
| Dynamic olfactometry (EN 13725) | Odor concentration in ouE/m³ | Emission from each source, treatment efficiency |
| Field inspection (EN 16841) | Presence of odor in the surrounding area, on a grid of points or along the plume | Actual impact on neighbors |
| Chemical analysis (chromatography, sorbent tubes) | Specific compounds | Finding out what smells and sizing the installation |
| H₂S and ammonia analyzers | Continuous or spot concentration | Process control and safety |
| Electronic noses | Trends and alarms | Continuous monitoring, after calibration at the plant |
In olfactometry, a panel of assessors smells diluted samples until they can no longer detect the odor. Together with the flow rate, this makes it possible to calculate how much odor each source emits. Measurements of H₂S, ammonia and VOCs complete that result, and the equipment is sized with them.
For the measurement to be meaningful, samples are taken under the worst reasonable conditions: during unloading, compost turning, centrifuge start-up and hot weather. Samples containing sulfur compounds degrade in the bag, so they have to be analyzed quickly. And if the laboratory’s limit of quantification is above the compound’s odor threshold, a “not detected” result does not mean there is no odor.
There are many products on the market for spraying around the plant perimeter or injecting into ducts: masking fragrances, neutralizers that supposedly react with the compounds and biological or enzymatic additives. They can help during start-ups, shutdowns or one-off unloading. But a product that changes the odor where it is applied does not necessarily reduce what leaves the plant, and some add a new odor or more VOCs. If they are used, olfactometry measurements have to be taken before and after, under the same conditions. As the main solution for a significant source near homes, they are no substitute for capturing and treating the air.
The biofilter has a low operating cost, but needs a lot of space and copes poorly with peaks. The scrubber is compact and stable, but uses reagents. With a lot of ammonia or H₂S, the two are often combined.
Because many odorous compounds can be detected at concentrations thousands of times lower than occupational exposure limits.
Rarely. They can help on a one-off basis, but they are no substitute for capturing and treating the air from a permanent odor source.
AUTHOR
WIZZUM engineering teamWe design and commission wastewater and gas treatment installations for industry, from benchmarking and FEED engineering to start-up.
NEED HELP?
15/04/2025
How hydrogen sulfide is removed from extracted air and biogas: alkaline and oxidizing scrubbers, biotrickling filters, biofilters, bioscrubbers and adsorbents.
Read the article →
03/02/2026
Odor is not a subjective complaint but a measurable parameter. Tests show how efficiently an odor control installation works.
Read the article →
11/06/2024
What to measure before designing a gas treatment installation, for how long, and which mistakes drive up the investment or leave the unit unable to meet the limit.
Read the article →
OFFICE
Avda. Cabrera, 36
08302 Mataró (Barcelona), Spain
info@wizzum.com
© 2026 Wizzum. All rights reserved.
